menu

menu

our menu

View our menu offerings below, or please visit Grubhub, Uber Eats or DoorDash.

smoked-wahoo-dip-600
starters

SEASONAL FISH DIP
Smoked Fish dip, assorted crackers, cucumbers. 12.50

Calamari
Lightly seasoned, flash fried, marinara. 12.00

Cheese Curds
Hand-battered cheese curds, marinara. 9.00

CRAB STUFFED SHRIMP
Five large crab cake stuffed shrimp, old bay cream sauce, fresh lemon. 11.00

hemingways-salads-menu-caesar
soups & salads

Classic Caesar Salad
Locally grown romaine, shredded parmesan, house-made garlic croutons, Caesar dressing. 10.00
Add Chicken 5.00
Add Salmon 9.00

Cobb Salad
Locally grown romaine and spring greens, heirloom tomatoes, avocado, bacon, farm fresh egg, bleu cheese, house-made garlic croutons, grilled chicken breast. 15.00

New England-Style Clam Chowder
Chef Marcel Bonetti Classic Recipe.
Cup 4.75
Bowl 6.75

tacos-menu-tile
specialty sandwiches

Served with French Fries.

World Famous Islamorada Sandwich
Seasonal catch, sautéed onions, American. 17.25

Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, avocado, bacon, pepperjack, lettuce, tomato. 13.50

Papa’s Shrimp Taco
Flour tortillas, spicy shrimp, mango pico de gallo, lime sour cream, cabbage slaw. 15.50

Build Your Own Burger
Angus beef patty, lettuce and tomato. 12.75
Choice of two toppings:
Sauteed Mushrooms
Sauteed Onions
Bacon
Jalapenos
American
Bleu Cheese
Pepperjack
Cheddar

hemingways-entrees-shrimp-bonetti
entrees

Add House or Caesar Salad 2.25
Add a Shrimp Skewer onto any entree 6.00
Add Crab Cake 7.00

Fish and Chips
Flaky cod, beer batter, house-made tartar sauce, French fries. 14.75

Shrimp Bonetti
Created by Auguste Escoffier
Medal of Merit winner Chef Marcel Bonetti, CEC, AAC.
Sautéed shrimp, garlic, white wine, combination of parmesan cream sauce and herbed tomato sauce, fettuccine. 17.00

Catfish Platter
Hand-breaded in cornmeal, French fries, tartar sauce. 16.00

FRIED OR COCONUT Breaded Shrimp
Choice of breaded or coconut breaded, French Fries. 16.00

Crab Stuffed Shrimp
Eight large crab cake stuffed shrimp, old bay cream sauce, fresh lemon, mashed potatoes, fresh vegetable. 18.00

Grilled 8 oz Filet
Hand-cut, mashed potatoes, fresh vegetable. 40.00

Brown Sugar Glazed Salmon
Mashed potatoes, fresh vegetable. 23.00

Pan Seared Halibut
Thyme Butter Pan sauce, mashed potatoes, fresh vegetable. 32.25

Genny Morris Fried Chicken
10 oz. airline chicken breast, light and crispy breading, country gravy, mashed potatoes, fresh vegetable. 17.50

Chicken Fingers
Hand-breaded chicken tenders, French fries, honey mustard. 13.50

key-lime-pie-desserts
DESSERT

Homemade Key Lime Pie

Cookie Sundae

Rocky Road Brownie Skillet

drinks

menu-beer
beer list

Angry Orchard
Blue Moon
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors Light
Corona
Michelob Ultra
Miller Lite
O’doul’s Non-Alcoholic
Slightly Mighty IPA
Truly

menu-wine
wine list

SUNSET SANGRIA
Eppa Organic Sangria, Fresh Fruit. 9.00

white

Riesling
Chateau Ste. Michelle
8.00 / 32.00

Pinot Grigio
Mezzacorona
8.00 / 32.00

Sauvignon Blanc
Oyster Bay
9.00 / 36.00

Chardonnay
Wente
9.00 / 36.00

White Zinfandel
7.00 / 27.00

red

Pinot Noir
Kenwood
9.00 / 36.00

Merlot
14 Hands
8.00 / 32.00

Cabernet Sauvignon
Josh Cellars
9.00 / 36.00

menu-cocktails
cocktails

The Fishbowl
Made for Two - Smirnoff Vodka, Tanqueray Gin, Cruzan Light Rum, Sour, DeKuyper Blue Curacao, Sprite. 15.25

Grey Goose Fizz
Grey Goose Vodka, St. Germaine Elderflower, Sour, Soda. 9.25

Top Shelf LIT
Absolut, Beefeater, Bacardi Superior, Sauza, Sour, Splash of Cola. 9.00

Morris Mule
Tito’s Handmade Vodka, Ginger Beer, Fresh Squeezed Lime. 9.25

Old Marksman
Makers Mark, Simple Syrup, Bitters. 9.25

Berry Mojito
Bacardi Dragonberry, Sour, Fresh Blueberries, Mint, Soda. 9.00

Hurricane
Bacardi Cuatro, Passion Fruit Puree, Orange Juice, Grenadine, Sour. 10.25

Pina Colada
Bacardi Superior, Pineapple Juice, Cream of Coconut.  9.00

Big Apple Sour
Jim Beam, Jim Beam Apple, Sour, Red Wine Float. 9.50

Anglers Bloody Mary
Tito’s Vodka, Bloody Mary Mix, Jerky Garnish. 10.25

Signature Margarita
Patron Silver Tequila, Patron Citronge, Sour. 10.25

Strawberry Margarita
Sauza, Strawberry Puree, Sour. 8.75

COSMOPOLITAN
Absolut Citron, Grand Marnier, Sour, Cranberry. 9.00